![]()
CHAPTER 151. GENERAL PROVISIONS Sec.
151.1. Definitions.
151.2. Purpose.
151.3. Scope of recoverable damages.
151.4. Moving and related expenses.
151.5. Replacement housing for homeowners.
151.6. Replacement rental housing.
151.7. Replacement housing down payment.
151.8. Time and conditions of payment.
151.9. Eligibility for special damages for displacement.
151.10. Contingent attorney fees.
151.11. Information and advice about special damages.
151.12. Grievance procedures.Authority The provisions of this Chapter 151 issued under the Eminent Domain Code (26 P. S. § § 1-2011-902), unless otherwise noted.
Source The provisions of this § 151.1 amended through June 20, 1980, effective June 21, 1980, 10 Pa.B. 2463. Immediately preceding text appears at serial page 18858.
Notes of Decisions Value in Place
The trial court erred when it determined that a retail jewelry businesss inventory had value in place, where the inventory, i.e., jewelry for retail sale, can easily be moved without substantially destroying or diminishing its value. MS Jewelers, Inc. v. Redevelopment Authority of the City of Philadelphia, 725 A.2d 1245 (Pa. Cmwlth. 1999); appeal denied 747 A.2d 372 (Pa. 1999).
§ 151.2. Purpose.
The provisions of this chapter have been promulgated to insure the following:
(1) That payment of special damages for displacement, authorized by Article VI-A of the act (26 P. S. § § 1-601A1-606A) shall be made in a manner which is fair and reasonable, and as uniform as practicable.
(2) That displaced persons making proper application for a payment authorized for those persons under Article VI-A of the act (26 P. S. § § 1-601A1-606A) shall be paid promptly after a move or, in hardship cases, be paid in advance.
(3) That persons aggrieved by a determination as to eligibility for a payment authorized by Article VI-A of the act (26 P. S. § § 1-601A1-606A), or the amount of a payment, may elect to have their applications reviewed by the head of the acquiring agency or his designee.
(4) That displaced persons shall receive the maximum payments authorized by Article VI-A of the act (26 P. S. § § 1-601A1-606A).
(5) That each acquiring agency may obtain the maximum Federal reimbursement for relocation payment and assistance costs authorized by Federal statute.
Notes of Decisions Special Damages
This section allows a condemnee to elect to negotiate first with the acquiring agency in an attempt to settle issues of eligibility for or regarding the amount of special damages but does not preclude the condemnee from petitioning for an appointment of viewers. Bernotas v. Chester County Water Resources Authority, 555 A.2d 309 (Pa. Cmwlth. 1989).
§ 151.3. Scope of recoverable damages.
The provisions of this § 151.4 amended through June 20, 1980, effective June 21, 1980, 10 Pa.B. 2462. Immediately preceding text appears at serial pages (18861) and (23367).
Notes of Decisions Dislocation Damages
The period relevant for the determination of whether a substantial loss of existing patronage occurred is not the calendar year of the relocation, but rather a period of at least six months at the new location; and, if the business enjoyed an increase in net earnings during that period, dislocation damages cannot be awarded. Eisenberg v. Redevelopment Authority, 386 A.2d 163 (Pa. Cmwlth. 1978).
When the only loss suffered by relocation of a business was that of specific individual customers who were immediately replaced in greater numbers by other customers at the new location, there was no loss in earnings upon dislocation and the business is not entitled to dislocation damages. Neumann v. Department of Transportation, 372 A.2d 1240 (Pa. Cmwlth. 1977).
Moving Expenses
A horse business and a hay growing and cattle operation constitute only one business for moving expense purposes if the same persons own, control and manage both businesses, the same land was shared by both businesses, the income from both businesses was reported in combined form on federal income tax returns, the income and expenses of both businesses were credited and debited to the same account, the horse business was the only one held out to the public, and the hay was grown to feed the horses while the cattle were raised mostly for the personal use of the owners. Baker v. County of Allegheny, 412 A.2d 190 (Pa. Cmwlth. 1980).
Occupancy
Occupancy requires more than mere right to possess or control property.the right must actually be exercised. Redevelopment Authority v. Stepanik, 360 A.2d 300 (Pa. Cmwlth. 1976).
Owner-Occupant
A property owner rented out part of the property as apartments, but had a bar and restaurant in part of the property, from which he lived upstairs, he was properly awarded business location damages, since such damages were based only on that portion of the property for which the owner qualified as an owner-occupant Redevelopment Authority v. Legosh, 394 A.2d 1089 (Pa. Cmwlth. 1978).
Relocation Damages
Tax returns for the two years immediately before and for one year immediately following the relocation of a business were admissible to prove that the business had prospered by the relocation and was not entitled to relocation damages. Neumann v. Department of Transportation, 372 A.2d 1240 (Pa. Cmwlth. 1977).
Search Expenses
Search expenses may be justified by production of a list of places visited, the distances traveled, and the dates of visits, and, if an hourly wage rate is not applicable, a daily wage rate may be substituted. Baker v. County of Allegheny, 412 A.2d 190 (Pa. Cmwlth. 1980).
If a condemnee occupies the property condemned both as a residence and as a place of business and suffers damages in the condemnation, the condemnee may be eligible for damages related to each aspect of the dislocation. If the unit occupied by the condemnee is a place of business and if the fair monthly rental value of that unit is in excess of $2500, the condemnee would be eligible for the $10,000 maximum amount of special dislocation damages allowed by 26 P. S. § 1-601A(b)(3). Department of Transportation v. Gaylor, 448 A.2d 656 (Pa. Cmwlth. 1982).
Validity
The provisions of 37 Pa. Code § 151.4 (relating to moving and related expenses) are valid since it complies with the intent of the Legislature, as expressed in 26 P. S. § 1-601A(b)(3), to deny special dislocation damages to landlords not physically occupying the premises condemned. Redevelopment Authority v. Stepanik, 387 A.2d 1292 (Pa. 1978).
The provisions of 37 Pa. Code § 151.4 (relating to moving and related expenses), formerly § 103.4(d) of the Uniform Relocation Assistance Regulations, was held to be consistent with 26 P. S. § 1-601A(b)(3), and not to be in derogation of an owners statutory rights in the determination of dislocation allowances. Redevelopment Authority v. Stepanik, 360 A.2d 300 (Pa. Cmwlth. 1976).
Cross References The provisions of this § 151.5 amended March 2, 1973, effective March 3, 1973, 3 Pa.B. 411.
Cross References The provisions of this § 151.6 amended through August 29, 1975, effective August 30, 1975, 5 Pa.B. 2262. Immediately preceding text appears at serial page (11024).
§ 151.7. Replacement housing down payment.
If a displaced person who is not eligible for a payment under section 602-A of the act (26 P. S. § 1-602A), or who elects the benefits available under section 603-A of the act (26 P. S. § 1-603A), purchases or retains a dwelling and moves it to another location, the displaced person shall be entitled to a payment under section 601-A(a)(1) of the act (26 P. S. § 1-601A(a)(1)), in an amount not to exceed the sum of § 151.5(c)(1)(7) (relating to replacement housing for homeowners) provided:
(1) The total payment will not exceed $4,000.
(2) The displaced person shall equally match the amount of the payment which exceeds $2,000.
Unless there is a demonstrated need for ready access of funds for condemnees who must borrow money to acquire replacement real estate, condemnees are not entitled to funds to be used in making down payments on replacement dwellings. Baker v. County of Allegheny, 412 A.2d 190 (Pa. Cmwlth. 1980).
§ 151.9. Eligibility for special damages for displacement.
Eligibility for special damages for displacement under Article VI-A of the act (26 P. S. § § 1-601A1-606A) is limited to persons, families, businesses and farm operations displaced on or after January 2, 1971.
(1) Persons, families, businesses and farm operations displaced prior to January 2, 1971, are eligible for the special damages for displacement as were provided in sections 608610 of the act (26 P. S. § § 1-6081-610) and sections 614618 of the act (26 P. S. § § 1-6141-618) (Repealed) prior to the December 29, 1971, amendment or by sections 304.1304.7 of the State Highway Law (36 P. S. § § 670-304.1670-304.7) (Repealed).
(2) Persons, families, businesses or farm operations displaced on or after January 2, 1971, and no later than December 29, 1971, are eligible for the greater of any item of special damages for displacement now provided in the act or previously provided in the act or the State Highway Law (36 P. S. § § 670-304.1670-304.7) (Repealed).
(3) Eligibility for the special damages for displacement shall be without regard to a final disposition made of a claim for the damages under prior law.
§ 151.10. Contingent attorney fees.
In order to assure that displaced persons actually receive the maximum amount of special damages for dislocation payable under Article VI-A of the act (26 P. S. § § 1-601A1-606A), the amount of the damages offered to a displaced person by an acquiring agency on its own initiative shall not be considered as damages paid to the displaced person for the purpose of determining the amount of a contingent attorney fee. This paragraph applies, not only to the original offer made by the acquiring agency to the displaced person, but to a subsequent increase in the offer initiated by the acquiring agency, whether made before or after the displaced person engaged the attorneys services; provided, however, that this paragraph will not apply to an original or increased offer or payment obtained as a direct result of the attorneys services on behalf of the displaced person.
§ 151.11. Information and advice about special damages.
(a) In order to assure that each displaced person receives the maximum payments to which he is entitled under Article VI-A of the act (26 P. S. § § 1-601A1-606A) the acquiring agency shall:
(1) Provide each potential displaced person with an information statement outlining the payments to which he may be entitled under the act at the earliest possible date prior to displacement.
(2) Make available at a reasonably convenient place, and at times which shall include hours other than normal working hours, a responsible person who can provide information and advice to displaced persons regarding the payments to which they may be entitled.
(3) Make available to displaced persons assistance in filling out and filing the required claim forms for the payments to which they may be entitled.
(b) In addition to outlining available benefits, the information statement shall contain the name, address, telephone number and hours of availability of the responsible person who can be contacted regarding the benefits, and shall outline the grievance procedure for appeal of a disagreement regarding the benefits, established in accordance with § 151.12 (relating to grievance procedures).
§ 151.12. Grievance procedures.
(a) Each acquiring agency shall establish a grievance procedure whereby the head of the acquiring agency or his designee shall hear the grievances of displaced persons regarding the acquiring agencys determination of their eligibility for or the amount of an item of special damages for displacement.
(b) Delegation of authority to hear appeals shall be in writing and shall be available for examination by the appellant. The authority will not be delegated below the level of the supervisor of the employe who made the initial determination.
(c) An aggrieved displaced person shall have the opportunity for a prompt hearing at a reasonably convenient time and place, or may appeal in writing, at his option.
(d) An aggrieved displaced person shall have the right to be represented by counsel and to present evidence, including evidence of comparable replacement dwellings, moving expenses and other matters bearing on special damage for displacement.
(e) The appeal shall be disposed of promptly, and the results conveyed to the appellant in writing.
Cross References This section cited in 37 Pa. Code § 151.11 (relating to information and advice about special damages).
No part of the information on this site may be reproduced for profit or sold for profit.
This material has been drawn directly from the official Pennsylvania Code full text database. Due to the limitations of HTML or differences in display capabilities of different browsers, this version may differ slightly from the official printed version.